Typological thinking: Then and now

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

A popular narrative about the history of modern biology has it that Ernst Mayr introduced the distinction between “typological thinking” and “population thinking” to mark a contrast between a metaphysically problematic and a promising foundation for (evolutionary) biology, respectively. This narrative sometimes continues with the observation that, since the late-20th century, typological concepts have been making a comeback in biology, primarily in the context of evolutionary developmental biology. It is hard to square this narrative with the historical and philosophical literature on the typology/population distinction from the last decade or so. The conclusion that emerges from this literature is that the very distinction between typological thinking and population thinking is a piece of mere rhetoric that was concocted and rehearsed for purely strategic, programmatic reasons. If this is right, it becomes hard to make sense of recent criticisms (and sometimes: espousals) of the purportedly typological underpinnings of certain contemporary research programs. In this article, I offer a way out of this apparent conflict. I show that we can make historical and philosophical sense of the continued accusations of typological thinking by looking beyond Mayr, to his contemporary and colleague George Gaylord Simpson. I show that before Mayr discussed the typology/population distinction as an issue in scientific metaphysics, Simpson introduced it to mark several contrasts in methodology and scientific practice. I argue that Simpson's insightful discussion offers useful resources for classifying and assessing contemporary attributions of typological thinking.

Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution
Issue number3
Pages (from-to)123-131
Number of pages9
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2018

    Research areas

  • Bauplan, body plans, Ernst Mayr, Essentialism Story, George Gaylord Simpson, morphological type, phyla, typological thinking, typology

Number of downloads are based on statistics from Google Scholar and www.ku.dk

No data available

ID: 199117088